Clinical trials are a type of research. They involve people and test health-related “interventions” to see how they work (see the next paragraphs for more on interventions). Clinical trials often answer questions like: Is the intervention safe? Does the intervention improve or cure disease, or help people live longer with disease than other treatments? Does the intervention help people feel better?
There are many types of interventions tested in clinical trials. While we often think about clinical trials being done to test drugs, they also test devices, genetic therapies, natural health products, psychotherapies, lifestyle and preventive care interventions, and many other things.
The interventions studied in clinical trials can be very experimental, with little to no evidence about how they might work in people (e.g. new drugs). Or they may already be commonly used by people but more evidence is needed about how they work.
Clinical trials are carefully designed and planned to make sure that risks to the people participating are minimized to the extent possible, and that the questions asked about the intervention(s) can be answered when the trial is finished.
Clinical trials are done to provide research data, or evidence, about the intervention(s) tested. This evidence helps in deciding what therapies or other interventions might work best for people. Ultimately the goal is to improve medical treatments and peoples’ health and well-being.
The evidence, or results, from clinical trials can be used in many ways. With very new or experimental therapies, clinical trials can provide information about an intervention’s safety and inform decisions about whether to keep testing the intervention. The results of clinical trials are also used by companies as they develop new therapies, by doctors and other health care professionals in their daily practices, and by regulatory agencies (e.g. Health Canada) to decide which drugs and devices are safe and effective for Canadians. Clinical trial results can also help decision-makers decide on how healthcare and healthcare resources or healthcare dollars should be allocated.
There are some things that you should look for in helping you determine if a clinical trial is a reputable or credible clinical trial:
Clinical trials are designed to answer specific questions about an intervention. They are usually designed by a group of people that can include researchers, doctors, scientists, statisticians, sponsors, and – more and more often – patients and/or caregivers.
There are different types or designs for clinical trials. The design will depend on many things, including what is already known about the intervention(s) and what questions need to be answered.
We provide here a summary of the different types of trials by phase, although there can be differences in design depending on the disease or health condition being studied.
These trials are also sometimes called ‘first in humans’ because it is usually the first time the intervention is tested in people. These trials aim to establish the safety, dose and side effect information of the intervention in a small number of participants (usually 20-80 people).
These trials aim to ensure the intervention does what it is supposed to do and to determine if the dose should be changed, and to continue to learn about potential side effects. This phase is carried out in a larger number of participants (about 100-300 people).
These trials are ‘randomized clinical trials’ and test how long the effects of an intervention last, and continue to learn about potential side effects. There are a large number of participants in this phase (usually 1000s of people). You can read more about randomization below.
These trials are also called post-marketing surveillance because they involve monitoring an intervention after it is being sold (that is, on the market). This phase studies long term effects and any side effects on a very large group of people.
In this video, Ms. Sharon Frietag talks about types of clinical trials and provides information about the different phases of therapeutic trials, their goals and how they work.
A common type of clinical trial is a “randomized” clinical trial. These are typically called “phase 3 trials”. In randomized trials two or more interventions (or treatment arms) are being compared to each other. When a trial is randomized, participants are assigned by chance to one of the interventions (or treatment arms). This helps to ensure the result of the trial is not biased.
There are other types of trials that are not randomized and participants know what intervention or treatment they will get if they participate. These are typically phase 1 or 2 trials and are done with treatments that are still in early testing for safety and effectiveness. Or they may be phase 4 trials that usually happen after a treatment is in widespread use.
Participation in a clinical trial is voluntary. If you are thinking about participating in a clinical trial it is important that you are provided with enough information to make an informed decision, an opportunity to ask questions and talk to others you may choose to (e.g. your family or friends) and the time to make a decision that is right for you.
A key part of the informed consent processes for most clinical trials is a document called the ‘informed consent form’ or ‘consent form’. This document should provide all relevant information about the clinical trial and be written in a way that is understandable to you. You should be given enough time to read it and ask any questions you may have. If you agree to participate, you may be asked to sign the consent form and should be provided with a copy of the form for your own keeping.
Informed consent is an ongoing process throughout a clinical trial. You can withdraw your consent to participate at any time. If you are in a clinical trial and your doctor or study team learn new information that might affect your willingness to continue to participate (e.g., new safety information about the intervention), you should be provided with this information.
A clinical trial protocol contains detailed documents with information on why the trial is being done, how the trial will be done, how the results will be gathered, analyzed and shared, and who is involved. The typical parts of a protocol include the following information about a clinical trial:
While participation in a clinical trial is one option, the other options to consider may be:
People find clinical trials in different ways.
Some people talk to their health care providers about finding a clinical trial. Health care providers may have different levels of knowledge and comfort talking about clinical trials. Depending on your health care provider’s experience or resources, they might be able to provide more information for you or direct you to a resource or person who can.
Some health charities and patient organizations have information about specific clinical trials on their websites (usually under a clinical trials or research section) or have a phone number you can call to speak to someone to help you find a clinical trial.
Hospitals, including both community and academic hospitals, carry out clinical trials and may be a source of information. Some hospitals provide information directly on their website about local clinical trials. If you phone or email the hospital looking for more information, you may have to make more than one phone call or send more than one email to find the right person to help you.
Some people use websites to help them find a clinical trials. Clinical Trials Ontario has developed a website to help you find a clinical trial, which you can link to here. Clinical Trial Ontario’s clinical trial finder uses a well-known website called Clinicaltrials.gov where many clinical trials from around the world are registered and detailed clinical trial information is provided. If you find a clinical trial you are interested in, the contact information is provided on the site.
You may also hear ads about clinical trials on the radio, and see them on tv, in the newspaper, on public transportation, in a doctor’s office, or in a hospital. Contact information is provided in these ads for people who are interested in learning more about these clinical trials.
There are some things that you should look for in helping you determine if a clinical trial is a good clinical trial for you, and may include:
There may be different reasons why you are not able to find a clinical trial. For example, there may be a clinical trial available but it is not at a location close to you or there may not be an intervention available yet to be tested for your disease or condition.
If there is a clinical trial available but it is being run at a location that is not close to you, there may still be possible ways to be in the study. You may wish to reach out to the study team contact to see if this is a possibility and how or if this might affect you (for example, will you have to pay for travel or accommodation?). You might also simply wish to keep up to date on research and check from time to time if there is a clinical trial available for your disease or condition.
The Clinical Trials Finder is a search tool created to help you look for a clinical trial. The source of information is a clinical trials database used by clinicians, researchers and companies around the world to provide public access to information about clinical trials. (*Note that not all trials are listed on the site.)
There may be costs associated with hospital visits, such as parking or transportation, or snacks/meals during your stay. You may also need to miss or take time off work to participate in the study or if you experience side effects as a result of participation. Other costs involved in your participation could be for extra costs not covered by your health insurance plan (if you have one), for example medications or treatments (such as physiotherapy) to treat side effects that you may experience. If you have private health care insurance, the insurer may not pay for these added costs.
You should not be asked to pay to participate in the study itself.
It is up to you to decide if the potential benefits of the clinical trial outweigh the potential risks, as well as to consider how not participating in the clinical trial at all may impact you. Potential benefits and risks will be dependent on the clinical trial and will be different for each clinical trial.
The informed consent form will have the potential benefits and risks of the clinical trial described.
You should ask your doctor or members of the study team any and all questions about potential benefits and risks until you feel satisfied.
When you participate in a clinical trial you may receive treatment that might affect your future medical care. This will depend on the type of treatment received, and the benefits or side effects of the intervention. For example, if you experienced side effects, your routine medical care may change to include treatments for those side effects, for a short or long period of time. Or the treatment you received on a trial may affect your access to other treatments in future.
You may also need additional follow-ups for study purposes for some time after the study and receive some tests or examinations related to this follow up.
Participation in the clinical trial may also limit you from participating in other clinical trials.
Clinical trials are a type of research. There are possibilities of experiencing benefits and risks, not all of which are completely understood or known until clinical trials are performed for an intervention. A number of precautions are taken to minimize risk to the extent possible. The clinical trial physician will closely monitor participants.
Clinical trial participants have experienced both benefits to their disease/condition and quality of life, as well as a range of side effects that have either gone away quickly or been serious, long lasting, and permanent. Some participants have died in clinical trials.
Some questions that you might wish to ask about the clinical trial include:
As you are asking questions about the clinical trial, you may wish to consider how participation might impact your normal routine. Understanding the commitment that you will need to make to the clinical trial and how this will affect your day to day activities will help you make your decision.
You can choose to end your participation in the clinical trial at any time without having to provide a reason – this is called withdrawal. If you choose to withdraw from the study, you are encouraged to contact the study doctor or study staff to let them know your decision or to ask them further questions before you make a decision.
If you do withdraw, you may be asked questions about your experience with the intervention, and to have laboratory tests and physical examinations considered necessary to safely stop your participation.
You may also be able to withdraw your permission to use information that was collected about you for the clinical trial and this would mean that you withdraw from the clinical trial.
If you stop participating in the study, you will continue to be seen by your regular medical team and receive your routine medical care.
If you left the study because of side effects, you may need treatment for these side effects, which may or may not be covered by private health insurance (if you have it).
After the clinical trial, you will continue as normal to be seen by your regular medical team and receive your routine medical care. If you experience side effects after the study, you may need treatment for these side effects, which may or may not be covered by private health insurance (if you have it).
You may also need to continue to be followed up on for study purposes for some time after the study and receive some tests or examinations related to this follow up.
A placebo is an inactive therapy (such as a drug, natural health product, or device) that looks like an active therapy. A placebo is not intended to have any effect on the condition being studied and is used to make the results of the study more reliable.
Generally, requests to reveal your assignment are not considered until the clinical trial has been completed and the results are known.
In some instances participants believe they are able to guess the arm of the clinical trial they are participating in given the results they experience in the clinical trial.
Depending on the study design, you may be aware from the beginning of the clinical trial which treatment group you are in, for example, for:
After the clinical trial, you will continue as normal to be seen by your regular medical team and receive your routine medical care. This routine medical care may be changed by your participation in the clinical trial depending on the benefits or side effects of the intervention that you experience. For example, if you experience side effects, your routine medical care may change to include treatments for those side effects, for a short or long period of time.
You may also need to continue to be followed up on for study purposes for some time after the study and receive some tests or examinations related to this follow up.
You may not be able to receive the study intervention after your participation in the study is completed. There are several possible reasons for this, some of which are:
The study doctor will talk to you about your options.
Participation in a clinical trial is voluntary. If you are thinking about participating in a clinical trial it is important that you are provided with enough information to make an informed decision, an opportunity to ask questions and talk to others you may choose to (e.g. your family or friends) and the time to make a decision that is right for you.
A key part of the informed consent process for most clinical trials is a document called the ‘informed consent form’ or ‘consent form’. This document should provide all relevant information about the clinical trial and be written in a way that is understandable to you. You should be given enough time to read it and ask any questions you may have. If you agree to participate, you may be asked to sign the consent form and should be provided with a copy of the form for your own keeping.
Informed consent does not always need to be provided in a written consent form. It may be provided in another, non-written form, and however this happens, it is always approved by a Research Ethics Board.
Informed consent is an ongoing process throughout a clinical trial. You can withdraw your consent to participate at any time. If you are in a clinical trial and your doctor or study team learn new information that might affect your willingness to continue to participate (e.g., new safety information about the intervention), you should be provided with this information.
Clinical trials study different treatments or interventions on their own or in combination with others. Different intervention types studied in clinical trials may include:
Other research site staff may include:
A clinical trial protocol contains detailed documents with information on how and why the trial is being done, how the trial will be done, how the results will be gathered, analyzed and shared, and who is involved. The typical parts of a clinical trial protocol are:
Another way of saying you get there by chance. A common type of clinical trial is a “randomized” clinical trial. These are typically called “phase 3 trials”. In randomized trials two or more interventions (or treatment arms) are being compared to each other. When a trial is randomized, participants are assigned by chance to one of the interventions (or treatment arms). This is important in helping to ensure the results of the trial are not due to health professionals or participants choosing what treatment arm they want to participate on.
An independent committee of people with different expertise (for example, law, medicine, ethics, community, etc.) that reviews the ethical acceptability of research involving humans.. The REB reviews all study materials including protocols and information or materials given to potential or actual participants with a view to ensuring participants are properly informed and free to make a voluntary decision about participating, and that a study’s potential risks are balanced with potential benefits. The REB continues to review information about the study as long as it is ongoing, including any adverse events and changes to the study along the way.
You can choose to end your participation in the clinical trial at any time without having to provide a reason – this is called withdrawal. If you choose to withdraw from the study, you are encouraged to contact the study doctor or study staff to let them know your decision or to ask them further questions before you make a decision.
If you do withdraw, you may be asked questions about your experience with the intervention, and to have laboratory tests and physical examinations considered necessary to safely stop your participation.
You may also be able to withdraw your permission to use information that was collected about you for the clinical trial intervention.
The study doctor may stop your participation in a study early, and without your consent, for reasons such as:
If this happens, it may mean that you would not receive the study intervention for the full period described in this consent form.
If you are removed from a study, the study doctor will discuss the reasons with you and plans will be made for your continued care outside of the study.
The #TalkClinicalTrials blog series explores different perspectives related to clinical trials. If you’ve personally taken part in a trial, supported a loved one who has, or been involved in some aspect of the clinical trials process, we’d love to hear your story. Email info@ctontario.ca or join the #TalkClinicalTrials conversation on social media.